Krymskiy inzhenerno-pedagogicheskiy universitet imeni Fevzi Yakubova
The article identifies similarities and differences in the tactics of anti-Russian propaganda deployed by the British and French press during the Crimean War. The comparison focused on two British and two French publications, typologically and genetically related: The Illustrated London News vs. L’Illustration, and Punch vs. Le Charivari. Observations revealed that British anti-Russian propaganda during the Crimean War was more virulent and cynical than its French counterpart. This was explained by a combination of factors. The British army suffered high combat and non-combat losses in Crimea; British public opinion was not prepared in advance for war against Russia; and a small, but still noticeable, segment of British society did not share the government’s military plans. Public sentiment had to be fostered «in an emergency» and fueled by extremely harsh «information dumps» that evoked horror and rage in the face of the «Russian threat.» Overall, propaganda tactics in England and France followed a similar pattern: on the one hand, fear of the «Russian threat» was instilled, while on the other, Russia was ridiculed, convincing the average person of an easy victory
information warfare, The Illustrated London News, Illustration, Punch, Charivari, Honga Massacre, Sinop Massacre, Roger Fenton.
1. Ajzenshtat M. P., Turlygin A. A. Istoricheskoe znanie vo vzaimnyh predstavleniyah britanskih i rossijskih liberalov konca XVIII–XIX v. [Historical knowledge in mutual perceptions of British and Russian liberals of the late 18th–
2. Ajrapetov O. R. 15 iz 1000 (Neboevye poteri russkoj armii) [15 out of 1000 (Non-combat losses of the Russian army)]. Rodina, 1995, no. 3–4, p. 114–115.
3. Alent’eva T. V. Anglijskij vzglyad na Krymskuyu vojnu [The English view of the Crimean War]. Nauchnyj vestnik Kryma, 2024, no. 4 (50), p. 1–18.
4. Belyaeva A. M. Neizvestnye ranee sostoyaniya litografij Onore Dom’e v sobranii Gosudarstvennogo Ermitazha [Previously unknown states of lithographs by Honore Daumier in the collection of the State Hermitage Museum]. 5.
5. Bobkov M. Yu. Osveshchenie Krymskoj vojny v gazete «The Times» (noyabr’dekabr’ 1853 g.) [Coverage of the Crimean War in the newspaper “The Times” (November–December 1853)]. Vestnik RGGU. Seriya:
6. Gete I. V. Iz moej zhizni. Poeziya i Pravda [From my life. Poetry and truth]. Moscow, Hudozhestvennaya literature Publ., 1969. 606
7. Gyubbenet A. Ya., Gyubbenet O. Ya. Professor hirurgii H. Ya. Gyubbenet i ego vospominaniya ob oborone Sevastopolya 1854–1855 gg. [Professor of surgery H. Ya. Gyubbenet and his memories of the defense of Sevastopol
8. Il’ichev A. V. Narrativ vostochnogo despotizma vo vneshnej politike Francii pervoj poloviny XIX v.: svyazi i analogii s sovremennost’yu [The narrative of oriental despotism in the foreign policy of France in the first half of the 19th
9. Krasavchenko T. N. Syuzhet o Krymskoj vojne (1853–1856) v britanskoj kul’ture [The plot of the Crimean War (1853–1856) in British culture]. Social’nye i gumanitarnye nauki. Otechestvennaya i zarubezhnaya literatura. Ser. 7:
10. Krasnopol’skaya V. Istoriya Krymskoj vojny – eto uchebnik, po kotoromu nuzhno uchit’sya reagirovat’ na segodnyashnie informacionnye vyzovy [The History of the Crimean War is a textbook for learning how to respond to
11. Mel’nikov V. A., Sharipova D. N. Krymskaya kampaniya 1853–1856 gg. – pervaya informacionnaya vojna v istorii protivostoyaniya mirovyh derzhav [The Crimean campaign of 1853–1856 – the first information war in the history
12. Migal’ A. S. Osmanskaya imperiya glazami anglijskih puteshestvennikov XVIII veka [The Ottoman Empire through the eyes of English travelers of the 18th century]. Istoriya i istoricheskaya pamyat’: mezhvuz. sb. nauch. tr. 18.
13. Nekrasova M. Yu., Barskaya O. V. Reprezentaciya obraza protivnika v britanskom gazetnom diskurse Krymskoj vojny [Representation of the image of the enemy in the British newspaper discourse of the Crimean War]. Mir
14. Orekhov V. V. «Russkij mif» i «kompleks markiza de Kyustina». Chast’ II: «Severnyj koloss» v kontekste informacionnoj vojny [“The Russian Myth” and the “Marquis de Custine Complex”. Part II: “The Northern Colossus” in the
15. Orekhova L. A., Orekhov V. V., Pervyh D. K., Orekhov D. V. Krymskaya Iliada. Krymskaya (Vostochnaya) vojna 1853–1856 godov glazami sovremennikov: literatura, arhivy, pressa [Crimean Iliad. Crimean (Eastern) War of
16. Orlov A. A. «Astrein vek». Velikobritaniya, Rossiya i problema novogo mirovogo poryadka v evropejskoj politike pervoj poloviny XIX veka (1815–1854 gg.): monografiya [«The Age of Astreya.» Great Britain, Russia and the
17. Orlov A. A. Britanskaya prorossijskaya publicistika epohi Krymskoj vojny (na primere broshyury «Krest protiv Luny», 1854) [British pro-Russian journalism of the Crimean War era (based on the brochure “The Cross Against the
18. Perepiska Ekateriny Velikoj s gospodinom Volterom. V: 2-h kn. [Correspondence of Catherine the Great with Mr. Walter. In: 2 books]. Moscow, 1803, vol. 1–2.
19. Prutckov G. V. Istoriya zarubezhnoj zhurnalistiki. 1800–1929 [History of Foreign Journalism: 1800–1929]. Moscow, Aspekt Press Publ., 2010. 416 p.
20. Prutckov G. V. Francuzskaya i britanskaya pressa o Krymskoj vojne (1854–1856 gg.): u istokov informacionnyh vojn [French and British press on the Crimean War (1854–1856): at the origins of information wars]. I
21. Rychkov S. Yu. «Pobudit’ vse evropejskie dvory k tomu, chtoby oni… vynesli Rossii mezhdunarodnyj prigovor»: anglijskaya provokaciya na myse Hanko v period Krymskoj vojny [“To induce all European courts to… pass an
22. Sergeev V. V. Politika Velikobritanii nakanune i vo vremya Krymskoj vojny v istoricheskoj publicistike P. A. Chihacheva [British policy on the eve and during the Crimean War in the historical journalism of P. A. Chikhachev].
23. Sidorova O. G. Izobrazhenie Krymskoj vojny v anglijskoj literature [Portrayal of the Crimean War in English Literature]. Izvestiya Ural’skogo federal’nogo universiteta. Ser. 2, Gumanitarnye nauki, 2014, no. 3 (130), p. 106–113.
24. Tan’shina N. P. Na ideologicheskom fronte Krymskoj vojny: obraz Rossii vo francuzskoj literature i publicistike [On the ideological front of the Crimean War: the image of Russia in French literature and journalism]. Francuzskij
25. Tan’shina N. P. Rusofobiya: Istoriya izobreteniya straha [Russophobia: The history of the invention of fear]. Moscow, Konceptual , 2023. 496 p.
26. Tarle E. V. Samoderzhavie Nikolaya I i francuzskoe obshchestvennoe mnenie [The autocracy of Nicholas I and French public opinion]. Byloe. Peterburg, 1906, n 9. p. 12–42; 10, p. 125–159.
27. Tarle E. V. soch.: V 12-ti t. T. 8 [Collected works: In 12 volumes. Vol. 8]. Moscow, AN SSSR Publ., 1959. 560 p.
28. Frank S. Vidimaya i nevidimaya vojna v Krymu (Nachalo medijnoj epohi i «Sevastopol’skie rasskazy» L’va Tolstogo) [Visible and Invisible War in Crimea (The Beginning of the Media Age and Leo Tolstoy’s “Sevastopol
29. Francev V. A. Pushkin i pol’skoe vosstanie 1830–1831 g. Opyt istoricheskogo kommentariya k stihotvoreniyam «Klevetnikam Rossii» i «Borodinskaya godovshchina» [Pushkin and the Polish Uprising of 1830–1831: An Attempt
30. Hrapunov N. I. Bahchisaraj Edvarda-Dan’ela Klarka: Vostok, Rossiya i Krym [Bakhchisaray Edward-Daniel Clark: East, Russia and Crimea]. Problemy istorii, filologii, kul’tury, 2014, no. 4, p. 141–153.
31. Hrapunov N. I. Rossiya v Krymu – civilizator ili ugnetatel’? Obrazy imperskoj vlasti v polemike travelogov konca XVIII – pervoj poloviny XIX v. [Russia in Crimea – Civilizer or Oppressor? Images of Imperial Power in the
32. Hrapunov N. I. Formirovanie obraza Kryma v anglijskoj literature puteshestvij konca XVIII – nachala XIX v.: Dis. … dokt. ist. nauk [Formation of the image of Crimea in English travel literature of the late 18th – early 19th
33. Alleged Capture of Sebastopol // The Illustrated London News, 1854, 7 October, no. 706, p. 334.
34. Caraguel C. Beau trait de l’empereur Nicolas // Le Charivari, 1854, 30 Novembre
35. Caraguel C. Les bulletins du Caucase // Le Charivari, 1853, 22 Octobre
36. Caraguel C. Les cornettes reparaissent // Le Charivari, 1854, 24 December, p. 1.
37. Chargeons les Russes. Album de quarante caricatures. Paris, Charivari, [1854]. 40
38. Delord T. Considération sur la mort de Nicolas 1er. Datées de la place de la bourse // Le Charivari, 1855, 5 Mars, p. 1.
39. Delord T. Les portraits de nouveau tzar // Le Charivari, 1855, 11 Mars, p. 1
40. Durand-Brager H. Combat d’Eupatoria et de la tour Malakoff // L’Illustration, 1855, 17 Mars, no. 629, p. 163–164.
41. Enthusiasm in Effigy // Punch, 1854, 11 February, no. 655, p. 49.
42. Féré. Le maréchal Le Roy de Saint-Arnaud, général en chef de l’armée d’Orient // L’Illustration, 1854, 18 Mars, no. 577, p. 168–169.
43. Féré. Lord Raglan, commandant en chef de l’armée anglaise en Orient // L’Illustration, 1854, 18 Mars, no. 577, p. 169.
44. Historical Summary of the Russian War: from its Commencement to the Present Time // The Illustrated London News, 1854, 11 September, no. 705, p 317–330.
45. Killed and Wounded in the Battle of Alma // The Illustrated London News, 1854, 7 October, no. 706, p. 334.
46. Les Cosaques pour rire. Paris, Charivari, 1854. 37 p.
47. L’Illustration est en mesure… // L’Illustration, 1854, 11 Mars, no. 576, p. 147.
48. London, Saturday, June 23, 1855 // The Illustrated London News, 1855, 23 June, no. 749, p. 638.
49. Marchal de Lunéville Ch. L’empereur Alexandre II et l’impératrice de Russie // L’Illustration, 1855, 17 Mars, no. 629, p. 161–162.
50. Melot M. La Guerre de Crimee et les heures sombres de Daumier (1856–1859) //2021, no. 2, p. 31–37.
51. Muscovite Holiness // Punch, 1855, 28 July, p. 39.
52. Histoire de la semaine // L’Illustration, 1854, 11 Mars, no. 576, p. 146–147.
53. Histoire de la semaine // L’Illustration, 1854, 25 Novembre, no. 613, p. 353.
54. Pity for the foe // Punch, 1855, 25 August, p. 80.
55. A Proposal to the Peace Society // Punch, 1855, 9 June, no. 726, p. 219.
56. Rosier L. Fantaisie par Marc // L’Illustration, 1855, 6 Janvier, no. 619, p. 2.
57. Russian View of Alma // Punch, 1854, 14 October, no. 692, p/ 143.
58. Sinope Remembered // Punch, 1854, 4 November, no. 695, p. 178.
59. The Bane and the Antidote // The Illustrated London News, 1854, 16 December, no. 717, p. 626.
60. The Cross and the Sword // Punch, 1855, 27 January, no. 707, p. 33.
61. The Czar’s Water Colour // Punch, 1854, 11 February, no. 655, p. 48.
62. The Laureate’s View of War // Punch, 1855, 18 August, p. 69.
63. The Illustrated London News // Available from: https://ru.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Illustrated_London_News (accessed 23.10.2025).
64. The Russian Eagle // Punch, 1855, 6 January, no. 704, /. 3.
65. The Victory in the Crimea // The Illustrated London News, 1854, 7 October, no. 706, p, 333–334.
66. The War against the Barbarians // The Illustrated London News, 1854, 11 February, no. 668, p. 117–118.
67. The Women’s Friend Society // Punch, 1855, 6 October, p. 135.
